Apple Mail Sync Settings on Two Macs: What Syncs and What Doesn't

The short answer
Between two Macs, Apple Mail syncs messages and server-side folders through your IMAP account. Per Apple, rules, signatures, smart mailboxes and VIPs also sync through iCloud once Sync this Mac is on for Mail. Layout and junk-filter training stay on each Mac, and Synchronize All Accounts only refreshes accounts from the server.
Apple Mail on two Macs: messages and folders sync via IMAP; rules, signatures, smart mailboxes and VIPs sync via iCloud when Mail sync is on.
On this page
You set Apple Mail up the way you like it on one Mac: rules that file newsletters, a smart mailbox for everything waiting on a reply, a signature per account, a VIP list. Then you open your second Mac and the inbox looks like day one. The usual cause is that mail itself syncs from the server, while Mail's own settings need a separate switch in System Settings.
Apple documents that switch. For Mail rules, signatures, smart mailboxes and VIPs, Apple says they stay up to date across your Macs when Mail sync is turned on for iCloud and Mail is selected in iCloud Drive. This guide shows what syncs, how to turn it on, what still has to be copied by hand, and what the Synchronize All Accounts menu command really does.
The steps are written for macOS 27, the current release. Apple's instructions cover macOS 13.3 and later, so macOS 26 (Tahoe) works the same way, and the label differs only on the oldest versions.
Which Apple Mail settings sync between two Macs, and which don't?#
Two different mechanisms are at work. Your messages and mail folders live on the mail server, so IMAP accounts show the same mail on every device. Mail's own settings are a different layer, and they sync only through iCloud and only for the items Apple lists. Anything Apple does not list should be treated as set per Mac.
| Item | Syncs between Macs? | How | If it does not appear |
|---|---|---|---|
| Messages and folders on IMAP accounts | Yes | Through the mail server | Add the same account on the second Mac and let it finish its first download |
| Messages on POP accounts | No | POP downloads mail to the Mac it is set up on | Switch to IMAP where your provider offers it |
| On My Mac mailboxes | No | Stored only on that Mac, not on any server | Create the folder under an account and move the messages into it |
| Mail rules | Yes, per Apple | iCloud, with Mail sync on; sound and script files attached to rules do not sync | Turn on Sync this Mac, then re-add rule attachments by hand |
| Signatures | Yes, per Apple | iCloud, with Mail sync on | Turn on Sync this Mac on both Macs, or paste the text in by hand |
| Smart mailboxes | Yes, per Apple | iCloud, with Mail sync on | Turn on Sync this Mac, or rebuild the criteria with New Smart Mailbox |
| VIPs | Yes, per Apple | iCloud, with Mail sync on; also syncs to iPhone and iPad | Turn on Sync this Mac, or add the senders again |
| Blocked senders and flag names | Yes, per Apple | iCloud, with Mail sync on | Turn on Sync this Mac |
| Junk filter training, layout, swipe actions, notification sounds | Not on Apple's list | Treat as set per Mac | Match them by hand in Mail > Settings |
What does Synchronize All Accounts mean in Mac Mail?#
Synchronize All Accounts is a command in Mail's Mailbox menu. In community write-ups it makes IMAP accounts reconcile with their servers across all folders, which goes deeper than Get New Mail, and the single-account Synchronize command works only on IMAP accounts. Apple's Mail User Guide does not document the command, so treat the exact behaviour as reported rather than guaranteed.
Either way, it is a refresh. Synchronize Mail does not copy your rules, signatures or other settings to the other Mac; that is what Sync this Mac does. If mail itself is slow to appear, see Mail not syncing on your Mac, and for a mailbox that stays wrong, how to rebuild a mailbox.

How to set up Apple Mail the same on a second Mac#
Do these in order on both Macs. Apple does not give a timing for how long settings take to appear, so check after a few minutes rather than assuming it failed.
- 1
1. Use the same Apple Account on both Macs
Open System Settings and click your name at the top of the sidebar. Confirm both Macs show the same Apple Account. Apple notes that settings do not stay up to date on any device where iCloud Drive is turned off, so check that iCloud Drive is on.
- 2
2. Turn on Mail sync
In System Settings, click your name, then iCloud, then Mail (it may read iCloud Mail). On macOS 13.3 or later, turn on Sync this Mac; on macOS 13 to 13.2 the button is Turn On. Also make sure Mail is selected in the iCloud Drive options. Do this on both Macs.
- 3
3. Add your other accounts on the second Mac
Open Mail > Add Account on the second Mac and add each Gmail, Outlook or other account. Choose IMAP where you have the choice, because IMAP keeps mail on the server where both Macs can reach it.
- 4
4. Check rules, signatures, smart mailboxes and VIPs
Open Mail > Settings > Rules and Signatures on the second Mac, and look for your Smart Mailboxes and VIPs in the sidebar. Rule attachments such as sounds or scripts do not sync, so re-add those by hand.
- 5
5. Move On My Mac folders if you want them everywhere
Folders under On My Mac exist only on the Mac that holds them. Create a matching folder under your IMAP account in the sidebar, then drag the messages into it so they sync to your other Mac and your iPhone.
- 6
6. Match the rest by hand
Layout, reading pane, swipe actions and notification sounds are not on Apple's sync list. Go through Mail > Settings on the second Mac and match what matters to you. Junk filter training is likewise per Mac, so mark junk on each machine.
What to do when settings do not sync#
If rules, signatures, smart mailboxes or VIPs do not appear on the second Mac, work through these checks in order.
- Both Macs must use the same Apple Account, and iCloud Drive must be on with Mail selected in its options. Apple says settings will not stay up to date on a device where iCloud Drive is off.
- Sync this Mac has to be on for Mail on each Mac, not only the first one. Toggle it off and on, then quit and reopen Mail.
- Rules that rely on sound or script files will arrive without those files. Re-add them by hand.
- Mail's Rules pane has Add Rule, Edit, Duplicate and Remove, and no Export or Import button. To copy a rule without iCloud, recreate it on the other Mac with Add Rule.
- A smart mailbox that looks empty may simply still be loading mail. Open it and check its criteria; if the criteria are there, give the mailbox time to fill.
- If mail itself is missing or threads look wrong, the problem is the mailbox, not settings sync. Try Mailbox > Synchronize All Accounts first, then see how to rebuild a mailbox.
Do not copy files out of the Library folder
A different approach: settings that live in your account#
If Apple's iCloud sync works for you, you may not need anything else. The case for a different client is a workflow that spans more than Macs, since Mail does not run on Windows or the web.
We build AI Emaily, an email client for Mac, Windows, iOS and web that connects Gmail, Outlook, iCloud and IMAP accounts in one inbox. Its rules and Personal Context, the instructions you set for how it writes and triages, live in your account, so a new machine picks them up when you sign in. It needs a connection and does not work offline, and the first sync covers about 60 days of mail. You can try it with a 7-day free trial on the Pro and Autopilot plans; details are on the pricing page.
Frequently asked
See it in AI Emaily
Keep reading
Sources

Written by
Nafiul HasanNafiul Hasan is an entrepreneur and AI automation system builder with 10+ years of experience turning messy, manual workflows into reliable automated systems. He designs and ships AI enterprise solutions end-to-end — the agent logic, the data plumbing, and the product people actually use — and founded AI Emaily to give busy professionals their attention back. He writes here from the builder's seat: what works, what breaks, and how to put AI to work without giving up control.