Gmail Signature on Replies: Set a Different or Shorter One

The short answer
In Gmail, open Settings, See all settings, then General and scroll to Signature. Create a short signature, then in the signature defaults set the new-email dropdown to your full signature and the reply/forward dropdown to the short one, or to No signature. Click Save Changes, then open a fresh reply to check.
Set a different Gmail signature for replies: open Settings, See all settings, then Signature defaults. Short on replies, full on new emails, plus fixes.
On this page
To change the Gmail signature on replies, open Settings, then See all settings, scroll to Signature on the General tab, and create a short signature. In the signature defaults, keep your full signature for new emails and pick the short one (or No signature) for replies and forwards. Click Save Changes and open a new reply to check.
This fixes the usual complaint: a logo, title, phone number and legal disclaimer repeated under every message in a thread. The control is easy to miss because it sits inside the normal signature editor, and the details below cover what to do if the reply signature does not appear or lands in the wrong place.
Before You Start#
You need a Gmail account, personal or Google Workspace. Workspace admins can set a default footer and manage signature settings for the organisation, so if the Signature section is locked or missing options, check with your IT team first.
Google's help page says a signature can hold up to 10,000 characters, and that images count toward that limit. You only need two signatures here: the full one you already have and a short one. Three lines is a good target for the short version: name, title and one contact method.
If you send from several addresses with Send mail as, pick the address from the drop-down above the signature box and set its signature and defaults separately. For a deeper look, see a different signature per alias.
How to Set a Different Gmail Signature for Replies#
- 1
Open the Signature section
Click the gear icon, then See all settings. On the General tab, scroll down to Signature. The quick settings panel that slides in from the right does not include signature management.
- 2
Create a short signature for replies
Click Create new, give it a name like Reply or Short so you can tell it apart from your full one, and type the content: usually your name and one contact detail, with no logo, banner or legal footer. Keep it to about three lines.
- 3
Set the signature defaults
In the signature defaults for your sending address, set the new-emails dropdown to your full signature and the replies/forwards dropdown to the short one. Gmail labels these slightly differently between versions, so look for the one that mentions reply or forward. To skip the signature on replies entirely, choose No signature.
- 4
Choose where the reply signature sits
Near the signature editor, look for the checkbox Insert this signature before quoted text in replies and remove the "--" line that precedes it. Tick it to place the signature directly under your new text, above the quoted history. Leave it unticked and the signature lands at the very bottom, below all the quoted text.
- 5
Save Changes and test in a fresh reply
Scroll to the bottom of the page and click Save Changes, then open a new reply on any thread. The short signature should load automatically. A window you opened before saving can still carry the old default, so close it and start again.
Why is my signature not showing on Gmail replies?#
If you expected Gmail to add a signature to a reply and nothing appears, the cause is almost always one of the settings below. The same table covers the opposite problem, the wrong signature appearing.
| Symptom | Likely cause | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| No signature appears in replies at all | The replies/forwards dropdown is set to No signature | Open the dropdown in the signature defaults and select your short signature, then save |
| Full signature still shows in replies | The replies/forwards dropdown still points to the full signature | Return to Signature, confirm the dropdown shows the short signature, and click Save Changes |
| Old signature loads in a reply you already had open | The compose window was opened before you saved | Close it and open a fresh reply; use Insert signature (the pen icon) in the compose toolbar to swap it by hand |
| Signature appears below all the quoted text | The checkbox for placing the signature before quoted text is not ticked | Tick Insert this signature before quoted text in replies and save |
| Signature missing or different on your phone | The Gmail app has its own mobile signature | Edit the mobile signature inside the app (see the table below) |
| Cannot edit signatures at all | A Workspace admin or signature tool manages them | Ask your IT administrator to allow user-level editing |
You can also pick a signature per message
Gmail Reply Signature Settings on Web and Mobile#
The reply default you set above lives in Gmail settings on the web. The Gmail app has its own mobile signature, which is the source of most confusion when the fix works on a laptop but not on a phone. Our guide to Gmail mobile vs desktop signatures goes through the differences in more detail.

| Where you send from | Separate reply signature? | Where to configure |
|---|---|---|
| Gmail on the web (desktop browser) | Yes | Settings, See all settings, General, Signature |
| Gmail app on iPhone and iPad | No separate reply setting in Google's help; one mobile signature per account | Menu, Settings, your account, Signature settings under Compose and Reply, then Mobile Signature |
| Gmail app on Android | No separate reply setting in Google's help; one mobile signature per account | Menu, Settings, your account, Mobile signature |
Apple Mail and other clients
Managing signatures across several accounts#
Gmail's settings take about two minutes and work well for one address. The friction grows with several Gmail accounts or aliases, because each has its own signature settings to keep in step.
We build AI Emaily, an AI-native email client that connects Gmail (through the Gmail API), Outlook and Microsoft 365, and IMAP providers. It keeps a signature library, lets you set a global default and assign a signature to each connected mailbox, and lets you switch or remove the signature for a single message from the composer. When your title or phone number changes, you edit the signature once in the library rather than in each account's Gmail settings.
One honest limit: AI Emaily does not apply a separate short signature to replies automatically. Today you set a signature per mailbox and swap it in the composer for a given reply. If a Gmail-style new-versus-reply default is all you need, the steps above are the right tool. If the pain is keeping signatures consistent across mailboxes, the 7-day free trial on Pro and Autopilot is a low-risk way to test it; check the pricing page first.
Frequently asked questions#
Quick answers on reply signatures in Gmail.
Frequently asked
See it in AI Emaily
Keep reading

Written by
Nafiul HasanNafiul Hasan is an entrepreneur and AI automation system builder with 10+ years of experience turning messy, manual workflows into reliable automated systems. He designs and ships AI enterprise solutions end-to-end — the agent logic, the data plumbing, and the product people actually use — and founded AI Emaily to give busy professionals their attention back. He writes here from the builder's seat: what works, what breaks, and how to put AI to work without giving up control.