Blog/ Apple Mail & iCloud

Apple Mail Conversation View Settings, Explained (Mac, iPhone)

Nafiul HasanNafiul Hasan· 7 min read
Diagram showing how Apple Mail conversation view groups email threads using message headers and subject lines on a Mac

The short answer

In iPhone Mail, Collapse Read Messages shrinks messages you have already read into one-line rows inside a conversation. Complete Threads also shows related messages stored in other mailboxes, such as your Sent replies. Organize by Thread groups replies into one conversation. On a Mac, the switch is View > Organize by Conversation.

What Organize by Thread, Collapse Read Messages and Complete Threads mean in Apple Mail, how to turn conversation view off, and why threads split.

On this page
  1. 01What do the Mail threading settings mean?
  2. 02How does Apple Mail decide what belongs in one conversation?
  3. 03How to control conversation view on Mac
  4. 04Why your thread split in two (and what to do about it)
  5. 05If you want more than a threading toggle

Apple Mail groups related messages into one conversation by default, and a handful of settings control how that looks: whether to group at all, how read messages are shown, which end of the thread is on top, and whether messages from other mailboxes are pulled in. The labels are easy to misread, so the table below defines each one in plain words, for iPhone and Mac. Jump to: the settings table, Mac steps, why threads split.

The iPhone labels live under Threading in the Mail settings. On recent iOS versions that is Settings > Apps > Mail > Threading; on iOS 17 and earlier it is Settings > Mail > Threading. On a Mac, the controls are in the View menu and in Mail > Settings > Viewing (called Preferences before macOS 13). Apple moves and renames these now and then, so if a label differs on your version, look for the closest match.

What do the Mail threading settings mean?#

Collapse Read Messages means that, inside an open conversation, messages you have already read fold down to a short one-line row, so only the unread or newest messages take up space. Complete Threads means the conversation shows related messages even when they sit in a different mailbox, for example your own replies in Sent. Organize by Thread (spelled Organise by Thread in some regions) means replies are stacked into one row instead of listed separately.

SettingWhat it doesWhere (Mac / iPhone)
Organize by Thread / Organize by ConversationGroups replies into one row. Turn it off if you want every message listed separately by date.Mac: View > Organize by Conversation. iPhone: Threading > Organize by Thread.
Collapse Read MessagesInside an open conversation, messages you have read shrink to one line. Turn it off if you want every message shown at full size.iPhone: Threading > Collapse Read Messages. Apple’s Mac guide lists no Viewing option with this name; on Mac use View > Collapse All Conversations or Expand All Conversations.
Most Recent Message on TopSets the order inside a thread. On shows the newest message first; off keeps the oldest first. Turn it on if you reply to long threads and hate scrolling.iPhone: Threading > Most Recent Message on Top. Mac: Mail > Settings > Viewing > Show most recent message at the top.
Complete Threads / Include related messagesShows other messages in the conversation even if they are stored in another mailbox, such as your Sent replies. Turn it off if threads pull in messages you did not expect.iPhone: Threading > Complete Threads. Mac: Mail > Settings > Viewing, the option for including related messages from other mailboxes.

Which version this covers

iOS 27 and macOS 27 are current; the menu paths here also apply to iOS 26 and macOS 26 Tahoe and, in most cases, to macOS 13 and later. Apple’s own pages for the iPhone Threading toggles are thin, so the iPhone descriptions above follow how Apple’s Mac guide describes related messages and how the toggles behave in practice. The labels can differ slightly by version.

How does Apple Mail decide what belongs in one conversation?#

Apple does not publish the exact algorithm, but conversation grouping rests on the same two signals most email clients use. The first and stronger is the header chain: a well-behaved client adds References and In-Reply-To headers to a reply, each pointing at the Message-ID of the message being answered (RFC 5322 defines these headers). The second is the subject line, which acts as a fallback when those headers are missing. For the deeper mechanics, see how email threading algorithms work.

Related messages from other mailboxes are included in a conversation by default on the Mac, according to Apple’s Mail guide, which is why your Sent replies usually appear inside the thread without any setup.

How to control conversation view on Mac#

These steps cover the controls most Mac users need. Labels follow Apple’s Mail User Guide for Mac and can differ slightly between macOS versions.

  1. 1

    Turn conversation view on or off

    Open the View menu and choose Organize by Conversation. A checkmark means it is on. Click it again to switch to a flat list sorted by date. This changes only how Mail displays messages on this Mac, not what is stored on the server.

  2. 2

    Show newest message on top

    Choose Mail > Settings, click Viewing, and select or deselect Show most recent message at the top. On iPhone and iPad the equivalent toggle is Most Recent Message on Top under Threading. The two devices keep separate settings.

  3. 3

    Include or exclude related messages from other mailboxes

    In Mail > Settings > Viewing, look for the option about including related messages. With it on, a conversation in your Inbox also shows your Sent replies and other related messages stored elsewhere. With it off, each mailbox shows only its own messages.

  4. 4

    Expand or collapse every conversation

    In the View menu choose Expand All Conversations or Collapse All Conversations. To open or close a single conversation, click the message count on its top message.

Why your thread split in two (and what to do about it)#

A split thread is usually a header problem. When a reply arrives without the References or In-Reply-To headers that point back to the original, Mail cannot link it with the strong signal and has to lean on the subject, which sometimes works and sometimes starts a second thread, especially if the subject was edited or the original message is old.

The common causes are a sender’s client or relay that strips or rewrites reply headers, a subject edited mid-conversation, and a message forwarded or composed from scratch rather than replied to, which gets a fresh Message-ID with no reference to the old one. Apple Mail has no merge-threads command, so the practical fix is upstream: ask the sender to use the Reply button instead of a new compose window, and keep the subject stable.

If a reply seems missing rather than split, check the related-messages setting first. A reply of your own that is not shown in the thread is usually sitting in Sent because Complete Threads (iPhone) or the Viewing option (Mac) is off. If you would rather not thread at all, see email clients with conversation view, or for Gmail specifically, turn off conversation view in Gmail.

Diagram illustrating how an email conversation forks into two separate threads when a reply message lacks References and In-Reply-To headers, causing Apple Mail to start a new thread branch instead of appending to the existing one
A missing header chain pushes Mail to guess from the subject, and a wrong guess starts a second thread.

If you want more than a threading toggle#

Conversation view only groups mail; it does not tell you which thread needs a reply. We build AI Emaily, an AI-native email client that sits on top of Gmail, Outlook, iCloud and other IMAP accounts. In Copilot mode it drafts replies in the voice you set in your Personal Context, and you approve every send. There is a 7-day free trial on Pro and Autopilot; see pricing.

Frequently asked

Nafiul Hasan

Written by

Nafiul Hasan

Nafiul Hasan is an entrepreneur and AI automation system builder with 10+ years of experience turning messy, manual workflows into reliable automated systems. He designs and ships AI enterprise solutions end-to-end — the agent logic, the data plumbing, and the product people actually use — and founded AI Emaily to give busy professionals their attention back. He writes here from the builder's seat: what works, what breaks, and how to put AI to work without giving up control.

EntrepreneurAI Automation System BuilderAI EnthusiastBuilds AI Enterprise Solutions10+ years experience
More from Nafiul
Ready when you are

Stop chasing split threads

AI Emaily drafts replies in the voice you set, and you approve every send. It works on top of iCloud, Gmail, Outlook and other IMAP accounts. 7-day free trial.

  • 7-day free trial
  • Cancel anytime
  • Every provider